Uncovering Hidden Talent Post Draft

Some GMs do their best work after the draft concludes

On April 26th, at the end of the NFL Draft, the final pick will be surrounded by an absurd amount of pomp and circumstance. Currently, the Kansas City Chiefs hold that pick, but with the flurry of trades that'll happen that weekend, that could very well change between now and pick number 257. They call that pick "Mr. Irrelevant." After that player is picked, a week-long celebration is had in Newport Beach, CA with a parade, banquet, trophy, and all kinds of fun. I guess you could call it a "Hey you were picked last, but you still matter!" celebration. That might sound rather silly like a consolation prize for being last, but in the grand scheme of it all, is it that bad to be picked last in the draft when some players don't have their name called at all?

Not only does Mr. Irrelevant receive his parade, banquet, and trophy, but he also still receives his four-year NFL contract like every other draft pick. What about the guys who weren't picked at all that are now tossed into the bin of undrafted free agents who don't have a draft pick investment as a small form of job security? Aren't they a little more irrelevant? Maybe, but if we're being honest, some players might prefer to go undrafted than be "Mr. Irrelevant." Not a single "Mr. Irrelevant" has been elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Only one "Mr. Irrelevant" has ever made the Pro Bowl. Countless undrafted free agents have earned Pro Bowl nods and around 8% of the Pro Football Hall of Fame enshrinees went undrafted. 

Another benefit to being an undrafted free agent is you almost have your pick of whatever team rings your phone number when the draft concludes. This makes finding those hidden gems after the draft a much more impressive feat for General Managers sometimes than the actual draft class. Let's be honest, while selecting a player in the draft relies on scouting and knowledge, sometimes it can all be dumb luck. If you're picking number one, and everyone in the draft industrial complex states a player is the consensus "can't miss" number one pick, picking that player isn't some masterful gambit. But finding a player in the pool of those who weren't drafted that makes a difference for your team can be. 

The Packers have a history of finding those undrafted gems. Perhaps the most notable of those gems in the last 20 years that the Packers signed post-draft would be CB Sam Shields. Shields was undrafted in 2010 and immediately became the number three corner on the Packers' roster after camp. Not only did he make the team as a UDFA but he made a big impact as such. He made six starts and appeared in 14 games with two interceptions. He had an even bigger coming-out party in the NFC Championship game when he made two interceptions and forced a fumble against Chicago to earn the Packers a trip to the Super Bowl that they eventually won. 

Brian Gutekunst would love nothing more than to find another Sam Shields after the conclusion of the 2025 draft. 

Finding that gem in 2025

Truthfully, no one has any idea who's going to be an undrafted free agent come the conclusion of the draft. Teams undoubtedly have their ranking boards and have an idea of who may go undrafted that they can set their sights on as soon as selections conclude, but they never know if a team might just select them. 

Several GMs have said that if they have a player they want who's projected to be a UDFA, why not just select them with their 7th-round pick? This approach makes sense especially if they think there's a chance they may not be able to "woo" them into signing. 

So far leading up to the draft, the Packers have had several late-round pick projected visitors. But only one of those I've seen a "late round/undrafted" tag on and that's Washington State OT Esa Pole. Pole was late to the game of football, not playing in high school but after playing in junior college, he started 21 games at left tackle for Washington State. In 2024, he had 489 pass-protecting snaps and did not allow a single sack. 

The 6'7 320 lbs lineman is certainly an intriguing prospect. He moves well in pass-pro using his long frame to keep defenders at bay but one knock on him so far has been choppy footwork. Outside of his size and lack of sacks against, what's intrigued me the most about Pole is his untapped potential. Having only played football a short amount of time, perhaps Pole's brain is ripe for the molding and a good offensive line coach can fine-tune Esa Pole into becoming a great asset to a team. 

There will be many outside of Esa Pole for the Packers to choose from come draft day. Brian Gutekunst is great at finding those diamonds in the rough and hopefully, this is a time when he finds another UDFA to contribute immediately. 

 

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.

__________________________

Greg Meinholz is a lifelong devoted Packer fan. A contributor to CheeseheadTV as well as PackersTalk. Follow him on Twitter @gmeinholz and Bluesky @gmeinholz.bsky.social for Packers commentary, random humor, beer endorsements, and occasional Star Wars and Marvel ramblings.

__________________________

0 points
 

Comments (11)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
T7Steve's picture

April 08, 2025 at 11:04 am

Thanks Greg. This is an exciting time of year.

How come the draft keeps getting further and further away? When do they start to put pads on?

0 points
0
0
splitpea1's picture

April 08, 2025 at 11:37 am

You forgot to mention the best Packer signing of them all, HOFer Willie Wood...The organization that has really excelled at finding great UDFAs is Dallas, including HOFers Drew Pearson and Cliff Harris. Also Nate Newton.

Back to the present and future, I want to start seeing Gute do his best work in the first three rounds--where you typically find your star talent and best chances for success.

0 points
0
0
LLCHESTY's picture

April 09, 2025 at 08:15 pm

Newton was a UDFA for the Redskins before getting hurt and ending up in the USFL before going to the Cowboys. Not sure you could count him as a "find" by them. The best story about him is agreeing to lose weight after Jimmy Johnson beat him in a 40 yard dash. Oof.

0 points
0
0
Major Snafu's picture

April 08, 2025 at 12:02 pm

I've posted this before and IMO only but I always thought that Ted T paid little to no attention to a players injury record. I concluded that the reason GB seemed to always lead the league in guys injured, even before the season started, was they were injury prone in college and Ted picked them for other reasons?
I kind of agree with others here that in the same light we pay way too little attention to the talent that is beyond the draft just sitting there. I've seen Gutt add guys to the practice squad just because they were there like last year or the year before. As in we dont have to spend time on these people they know us.
I say you must investigate all the possible players there well may be a real sleeper out their that seeped through the cracks. Hell Purdy is the best example possible.
Do the work!
I remember a few years back and again I think it was Ted, we were taking all these UCLA picks even thought UCLA wasnt a very good team but we had a scout living in the area feeding Ted crap.
ONe was a runner who couldnt make it through pre season and the other a QB who couldnt spell his own name. Most teams do a way better job of avoiding these guys.

0 points
0
0
GregC's picture

April 08, 2025 at 12:18 pm

Does anyone keep track of which teams have the most injuries? I ask this because fans of every team tend to assume their team leads the league in injuries.

In Thompson's 14 years as GM, he drafted five players from UCLA, which does not seem excessive to me. Two of them were first round picks: Datone Jones, who wasn't very good, and Kenny Clark, who was very good. The others were all day three picks. Brett Hundley was a fifth round pick who was a mediocre backup QB, which is a pretty typical level of performance for a backup QB.

0 points
0
0
T7Steve's picture

April 08, 2025 at 01:32 pm

Those QBs and others have generated more draft picks when teams like the Browns trade for them to be their starting QB.

0 points
0
0
LLCHESTY's picture

April 09, 2025 at 08:19 pm

I really like Franklin, it was a shame he got hurt and had to retire. Brought back memories of Tim Lewis going down back in the day and never playing again.

0 points
0
0
Leatherhead's picture

April 08, 2025 at 12:07 pm

72 guys under contract right now. Add in the draft and there's still room for about 10 UDFAs before we get up against the 90 man roster limit.

I would submit that somewhere between 45-50 of the guys that are going to be on the 53 man roster are already here.

0 points
0
0
BuckyBadger's picture

April 08, 2025 at 01:55 pm

Packers have 8 picks I believe, will sign probably more than a dozen UDFA and probably look at 20 more. FA isn't over yet either. The 53 man roster is also very fluid. I think the roster will turn over more than 8 or even 10 players.

0 points
0
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 08, 2025 at 02:22 pm

There is a reason why college prospects end up in the UDFA pool. NFL talent scouts have an exhaustive process and find the top prospects.

But good developmental UDFA football players can be found...and most teams know who those guys are too, so it is competitive, relatively speaking...if the prospect gets more than one offer.

Once in a while a future blue chip player will slip through the draft, but it is rare. Wilson has to be one of the top former UDFA's playing in the NFL right now, being a top back up to a top running team.

Even if they don't make the initial 53 or PS, they may later.

0 points
0
0
Alberta_Packer's picture

April 08, 2025 at 06:25 pm

It is easier to select hidden gems when a GM has more picks. It is no coincidence that the Packers have averaged over 11 picks in the last 3 drafts. This way a GM can take a free shot when doubling-up on a position (e.g. Tucker Kraft) This year - my guess is that Gutekunst will want a minimum of 10 picks in order to reinforce and / add depth to the D-line, O-line, WR, CB, TE, LB and QB groups. And with 10 picks he'll be able to double-up in select positions such as D-line and WR. Meanwhile - anything over 10 picks may almost guarantee a hidden gem - or two (think Zach Tom and Rasheed Walker).

0 points
0
0