What I find really interesting about this list is just how far down David Bakhtiari is on it. Here is a man who is arguably the best at his position in the NFL, who has started since day one, and whose RAS clocks in at a relatively pedestrian 6.72. It is almost like there is more to football than athleticism.

Lowry a better athlete than Clark? I’m a fan of Lowry, but this is difficult to believe.

On this list, the RAS seems particularly important when it comes to the secondary.

However, looking back at a few of the better Packer secondary members over the past 30 years, we have HOFer Butler at 5.05, Nick Collins at 7.04, and Tramon Williams at 7.24.

Also worth noting was Tony Mandarich's perfect 10.0 score.... Take all of this high RAS stuff with a grain of salt, because it doesn't always translate into sustained success on the football field.

What this shows is the danger of one perspective or measure in isolation.

What it shows is that excellent athletes can be real plus players, but it is no means a certainty. There are several reasons for this. Most obviously, instincts: football players that lack them generally aren’t good no matter how athletic.

Another is the fact that one facet can outweigh the rest. For example Adams and Bakh. Ignoring instincts, both posses short area quickness and technique that outweighs lack of exceptional scores in areas such as long speed or strength. A negative example might be Wirtel, if one score diverges from the norm sufficiently far, it may negate all the rest and make you a push over.

Finally, it gets muddy when there is positional uncertainty involved or the role as used doesn’t match the scoring assumptions for the player. For example, if Kenny Clark were scored as DE his score will differ from if he’s a DT. Lowry the same. We see this when you look at Deguara if he’s treated as a true TE, not the HBack type. His lack of size kills his TE score. Another example is Lazard: is he scored as a TE or WR? Is a LB a OLB or an ILB, is a S a quasi ILB or quasi interior CB?

Reader beware! RAS and other weighted metrics are useful, particularly if used in tandem, but that still doesn’t replace the need for scouting and relying on actual game play. Reactions can overcome a great deal. Douglas is a prime example from last year.

https://sports.yahoo.com/aaron-rodgers-reportedly-deals-place-163148005....

Will never happen, but I love doing a Mock before the draft simulators catch up with the Combine Results! Lol

Your score is: 52450 (GRADE: A)

Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 32: Jordan Davis, DT, Georgia (A)
Round 2 Pick 32: George Pickens, WR, Georgia (A)
Round 3 Pick 32: Boye Mafe, DE/OLB, Minnesota (A+)
Round 4 Pick 32: Khalil Shakir, WR, Boise State (A+)
Round 4 Pick 34 (COMP): Troy Andersen, ILB/OLB, Montana State (A+)
Round 5 Pick 32: Brian Robinson, RB, Alabama (A+)
Round 7 Pick 7: Ryan Hayes, OT, Michigan (A+)
Round 7 Pick 32: Grant Calcaterra, TE, SMU (A+)
Round 7 Pick 38 (COMP): Daniel Bellinger, TE, San Diego State (A+)

28: R1 P28 DL Jordan Davis - Georgia
59: R2 P27 WR Alec Pierce - Cincinnati
92: R3 P28 LB Troy Andersen - Montana State
131: R4 P27 WR Christian Watson - North Dakota State
140: R4 P36 WR Khalil Shakir - Boise State
171: R5 P28 OT Braxton Jones - Southern Utah
226: R7 P7 LB Darrian Beavers - Cincinnati
247: R7 P28 TE Daniel Bellinger - San Diego State
258: R7 P39 EDGE Isaiah Thomas - Oklahoma

Athleticism is great, but if a guy can’t play football then it’s not a valuable assessment. I would guess immeasurables between two similar players, but one scores higher than taking that player seems like a sound choice. Perhaps that athleticism gets them a higher ceiling.

Elite athleticism raises the ceiling a player can potentially achieve.

You still need technique, aptitude, desire, motivation, and understanding of the game to utilize those athletic traits.

But, yeah.. take two players who are on equal terms in those other areas, and the one with the god-given genetics is going to separate himself.

The draft is all about projecting how much more a young player is going to grow in the next stage of this career. A guy with greater physical tools at his disposal theoretically has a high ceiling. It's all a risk-reward assessment.

Guys I liked:

TE - Jelani Woods, or possibly Curtis Hodges

WR - Jameson William's (sure he is injured but a #1 WR, and Returner), Garrett Wilson, George Pickens, Isaiah Weston, Chris Olave

DL - Travon Walker, Devon Wyatt, Jordan Davis

Edge - David Ojabo, Boye Mafe, Amaro Barno

How FUNNY.... The long snapper who got run over in the playoffs, posted the 2nd best score,.. Hey he can run fast in Spandex, he just can't block or snap worth a damn.

Roadrunner's Email Support team is available 24/7 to answer questions, provide tutorials, and resolve issues with users' accounts.