Maggie’s Pre-Game Six Pack - 2024 Preseason Week 3
By MaggieLoney
We are now only two weeks away from the regular season, and only a handful of days away from roster cutdowns. While Matt LaFleur always likes to say his roster really consists of 69 players when you count the 16-man practice squad, there are still some hotly contested battles for the 53 active roster spots. The Packers play their final preseason game on Saturday against the Ravens, Green Bay’s only home preseason game. Here are some things to consider as we head into the final game.
1. Peddling History
The Packers have been riding bikes to practice since 1958 (roughly, according to team historian Cliff Christl).There’s nothing better than seeing players new and old ride bikes to practice with some of Green Bay’s youngest fans. Whenever a visiting team comes to Green Bay for joint practice, it’s become tradition for them to ride bikes to the field, too. Remember back in 2019 when Wisconsin native J.J. Watt broke a child’s bike on his way to practice?
On Thursday, Ravens players got to experience the ride for themselves on their way to joint practice. It’s always special to see players on other teams take part in one of the many traditions that makes Green Bay so unique. As fans, we’re lucky to root for such a storied franchise.
2. Tight Contest to the End
There are two roster locks when it comes to the tight end position, Luke Musgrave and Tucker Kraft. Behind them, though, it’s a wide open contest. Maybe Ben Sims is the leader for that third roster spot since he played in all 17 games for the Packers last season and has been one of the biggest special teams contributors all preseason.
It’s also possible that Tyler Davis gets the nod. He’s been with the team since 2021 and missed all of the 2023 season with a torn ACL. While he’s never scored a touchdown and has less than 100 career receiving yards to his name, he played 81% of special teams snaps for the Packers in 2022, leading the team.
It’s also possible that the Packers end up keeping four tight ends. But even if they do, Davis and Sims aren’t locks quite yet. Joel Wilson and Messiah Swinson round out the room. Wilson is the only tight end who’s had a reception in both preseason games. Swinson has yet to catch a pass.
For what it’s worth, Henry Pearson is also listed as a tight end on the Packers roster, but he was called a fullback in the roster transaction. Pearson makes sense for Green Bay in a more traditional H-back role, similar to how we saw Josiah Deguara utilized during his time with the team.
3. Who’s In(Side) and Who’s Out?
In what’s become possibly the most hotly contested camp battle (outside of maybe kicker), the Packers seem to have an abundance of riches at the inside linebacker position. Quay Walker and draft picks Edgerrin Cooper and Ty’Ron Hopper are roster locks. When the starters sat on Sunday against the Broncos, Isaiah McDuffie sat with them, which is notable and should mean he’s a lock, too. Eric Wilson, however, did play. Wilson and Hopper were the starters at linebacker with Walker and McDuffie sitting and Cooper still coming back from his hip injury.
In his first preseason action, Hopper passed the eye test, leading the team with 11 total tackles. Behind him, though, was Kristian Welch with 6. Welch also played 57% of snaps on special teams and has a fumble recovery and interception in two preseason games.
Going into the Broncos game, I would have penned in Wilson as a roster lock. He played 72% of special teams snaps last season for Green Bay and by all accounts has had a really nice training camp. But the Packers may not be willing to let Welch test waivers, either.
It would be surprising for the Packers to carry six linebackers on the 53-man roster, but it’s possible they’d consider it with Cooper still coming back from injury. They also will likely need more bodies inside as they make the switch to a more traditional 4-3 base (yes, I know their real base is more likely to be nickel). This is one position group to watch closely during the final preseason game on Saturday.
4. Undrafted Steak Ending?
Every training camp the Packers find an undrafted gem who makes the initial 53-man roster. It’s a tale as old as time. Last season, the Packers kept three undrafted players on the initial 53 when receiver Malik Heath, running back Emanuel Wilson, and edge rusher Brenton Cox all made the team. This year, it’s getting harder to determine who could be this year’s undrafted diamond, or if the streak will come to an end.
Kicker Alex Hale probably has the best shot at the roster, but with the Packers designating him as their player for the International Pathway Program, he wouldn’t count against the 16-man practice squad, so stashing him on the 53 seems unlikely unless he outright wins the job.
Receiver Julian Hicks has had a nice preseason and is a strong candidate for the practice squad, but the receiving room is ridiculously competitive, and it’s already unlikely Heath, Grant DuBose, and Bo Melton all make the roster. Hicks eclipsing any of the three for their spot would be hard to imagine.
Inside linebacker Ralen Goforth falls into a similar camp. Any other year, he’d be a strong contender for that undrafted spot. But as we just talked about in the third point, the linebacking core is loaded. He’s another ideal “next man up” candidate for the practice squad.
It’s entirely possible that the Packers covet an undrafted player who’s not currently on the roster. We’ve seen General Manager Brian Gutekunst make trades and sign players to the 53 that have spent no time with the Packers in training camp. But by that point, it’s not a true undrafted addition for the Packers since we’re talking about players already on the 90-man roster sticking on the initial 53-man roster on cutdown day.
5. Draft Pick Prestige
We’ve talked at length about Gutekunst’s love of his draft picks. If cutdown day decisions are between two players, the team normally gives the nod to the drafted player (at least recently). Let’s look at the 2023 draft class. Lukas Van Ness, Luke Musgrave, Jayden Reed, Tucker Kraft, Colby Wooden, Sean Clifford, Dontayvion Wicks, Karl Brooks, Anders Carlson, Carrington Valentine, and Anthony Johnson Jr. all made the 53-man roster, and Grant DuBose was on the practice squad all year. The only player not still with the team is running back Lew Nichols.
That trend could continue with this year’s class, as a lot of the draft picks are expected to play significant roles right away. Jordan Morgan is penciled in as the starting right guard, assuming he’s healthy for Week 1 in Brazil. Both Cooper and Hopper will see playing time this season. All three safeties, Javon Bullard, Evan Williams, and Kitan Oladapo have shown enough in the preseason to be contributors both on defense and special teams. MarShawn Lloyd is still recovering from his injury, but the third-round pick is certainly not in jeopardy of losing his roster spot. Jacob Monk has put together a nice preseason and has the feel of a roster lock. And Michael Pratt is a developmental quarterback and is someone the Packers might not want to gamble on losing. He’s had some eye-popping throws in training camp and could beat Clifford for the backup QB job.
That leaves only tackle Travis Glover and cornerback Kalen King as question marks when it comes to their roster status. Glover played 81% of snaps against the Broncos. Tackle depth is a concern for the Packers, but it doesn’t seem like Glover is ready to be the backup swing tackle. He’d stick on the 53 largely as a developmental prospect.
For King, he enters an incredibly crowded room behind Jaire Alexander, Eric Stokes, Keisean Nixon, and Carrington Valentine. Those are four roster locks. Depending on how many corners the Packers decide to carry, that means King could be competing with Corey Ballentine and Robert Rochell for what’s likely one or two final spots. King played 68% of defensive snaps against Denver and has played some on special teams, too. He’s a high upside player that’s made splashes in camp but also needs time to develop, similar to Glover. We’ll have to see if Gutekunst prioritizes draft status and potential upside or veteran stability when it comes to his final few roster decisions.
6. Raven About Joint Practice
I wasn’t lucky enough to attend training camp on Thursday to witness joint practice in person, but I thought I’d comb through the various tweets and reports from camp to let you know who stood out against the Ravens.
Let’s start with everyone’s favorite, the kicking competition! After an up and down battle all summer, Anders Carlson ended camp in the lead, making 59-of-72 attempts for an 81.9% success rate. Greg Joseph finished 57-of-73 for 78.1%, and Alex Hale ended 14-of-21 for 66.7% (per Andy Herman).
Also notably, Pratt took QB2 reps ahead of Clifford. He may be the leader in the clubhouse for the backup job. In second team reps, Williams led the defense with an interception of Ravens backup quarterback Josh Johnson. It’s Williams’ fifth interception of camp.
And let’s not forget about the first-team offense. Matt LaFleur was noncommittal when asked if his starters would play on Saturday. He said it would depend on how practice went. Clearly, the starters do not want to play in the finale. Love threw a pick early in practice to Roquan Smith, but the first-team offense ended the day scoring four touchdowns on four drives (per Rob Demovsky).
That’ll do it for training camp! In just two weeks, we’ll be back talking about the regular season. Cheers to an incredible season. Go Pack Go!
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Maggie Loney is a writer for Cheesehead TV and podcaster for Pack's What She Said. Find her on Bluesky at @MaggieJLoney.
__________________________




Comments (10)
dobber
August 23, 2024 at 07:51 am
Something to think about...it's possible the Packers cut BOTH of their kickers and sign someone on the open market the next week to avoid exposing someone to waivers. The new recall rules on putting players on IR (you can put two on IR prior to final cuts and still recall them) might come into play, too.
barutanseijin
August 23, 2024 at 08:09 am
Doubtful. Gutekunst isn’t as twitchy as the commentariat on fansites. Besides, what are the odds that a cutdown kicker turns out to be better over the long haul than what they have now?
dobber
August 23, 2024 at 01:11 pm
I don't know about "better" but they call these guys "replacement level" for a reason... ;)
LambeauPlain
August 23, 2024 at 08:20 am
Interesting thought.
I think Carlson has made the 53, albeit with a short hook (unless he whiffs tomorrow). Hale can be the international exemption as the 17th player on the Practice squad.
Joseph may be a PS candidate too or a new K from waivers joins Hale on the PS.
I don't believe a K better than Carlson gets cut...if so, why is he on the street?
LambeauPlain
August 23, 2024 at 07:56 am
Thanks, Maggie.
Of this year's draft class, Williams seems to be the star student of the class. It is impossible not to see his contributions when on the field. Reads plays at the snap quickly, flys to the ball and makes plays in both pass and run with hard tackles, pbu's, and INTs.
I would not be surprised if he has surpassed Bullard to start alongside Xavier. Either way, both Safeties will be two of the top 3 and the non starting rookie will still be the field often as first sub in at S, nickel, dime, in the slot.
And Packers still need to evaluate Oladapo's bet fit now that he's a healthy full go. Johnson Jr. has definitely taken a step up.
The problematic S room of 2023 in now crowded with talent with new additions Xavier, Williams, Bullard, Oladapo and Sophomore Johnson Jr. And I thought the WR room of 2022 was an amazingly fast makeover!
rob44rml
August 23, 2024 at 08:18 am
what is of MAIN CONCERN is the backup QB position if, in the unwanted scenario that JL goes down, we have a capable QB who is EXPERIENCED in the NFL and can handle that position to keep the team still inline to be able to challenge at the end of the season for a playoff spot. Those 2 'rookies' are not capable ! We have to have a seasoned journeyman to step in; a Tannehill (as much as I dislike his traits) or release from the 53 man team cut will still be more capable of running the offense. See what happened when AR was injured...the season was over !
LambeauPlain
August 23, 2024 at 08:22 am
Both Clifford and Pratt were capable yesterday vs the Ravens #1 D...and even better against their #2's.
MadJam
August 23, 2024 at 08:57 am
Anybody else you at practice yesterday? I wasn’t able to attend.
RCPackerFan
August 23, 2024 at 08:35 am
1. Peddling History
The bike riding is a great tradition. And it almost came crashing down at least for opposing teams when Lamar Jackson almost faceplanted yesterday.
2. Tight Contest to the End
It will be interesting to see what they do at TE. Do they keep 3 or 4? I think they end up keeping 3. By keeping 3 who do they go with Sims or Davis. I know they love Davis on Special Teams. But he hasn't look good since coming back from injury and Sims has been doing ok. Also Sims is 3 years younger. A player I like is Joel Wilson. He has really flashed. If he has a big game I could see him potentially making the 53. But right now I'd put him on the PS lock list.
There are two roster locks when it comes to the tight end position, Luke Musgrave and Tucker Kraft. Behind them, though, it’s a wide open contest. Maybe Ben Sims is the leader for that third roster spot since he played in all 17 games for the Packers last season and has been one of the biggest special teams contributors all preseason.
3. Who’s In(Side) and Who’s Out?
I do wonder if Wilson is a lock to make it. Seeing him playing in the last preseason game made me wonder that. I think he is a good bet to make it. But also with Welch looking really good and being 3 years younger, I could see them potentially looking to go younger.
4. Undrafted Steak Ending?
I believe the streak will end this year. The one guy I thought that had a very strong chance of making it was Donovan Jennings. But he has been hurt. I thought Bowden had a good chance of making it, but he has been cut twice, so that doesn't seem like it will happen. Joel Wilson I think is a possibility, but the chances are low.
5. Draft Pick Prestige
"That leaves only tackle Travis Glover and cornerback Kalen King as question marks when it comes to their roster status."
I have seen people say that Glover looked better then they thought initially in the Broncos game. I could definitely see them keeping Glover if they have seen something that they like. They have kept Caleb Jones and others around as development prospects. Glover could be that guy.
King I think right now will make the 53. But he could be cut to keep Ballentine or Rochell.
As of right now I think all the draft picks could make it. The last 3 picks Glover, Pratt and King obviously have the smallest chance of making it. I am not sure which will or won't make it but it will be interesting to see.
6. Raven About Joint Practice
It definitely sounded much better then the Broncos practice.
Its crazy that camp is over and we are 2 weeks from the season starting. Before that we have our last preseason game tomorrow and then cut down day is Tuesday.
ImaPayne2
August 23, 2024 at 12:36 pm
Thanks. Great observatons and commentary. As always this time of year is a myriad of choices that have to be made but maybe the toughest is who do we really want on that practice squad that can clear waivers. Every team has this problem for sure.
The thing that drives me crazy and I would assume many of the posters here too is, just how hard is it to kick a stupid football between two posts when its the only thing in life your ask to do and the only thing you practice day in and day out? I dont get it. Ya no one makes them all but cant you make most of them that are a decent distance.? DUH